Mickela Panday
When gunmen open fire in a community and women and children run for cover, the State cannot stand by. It must protect the public, confront criminal gangs and restore order. The question is whether its response will deliver lasting safety.
On November 10, the Maloney Buildings Housing Development was declared a closed area under the Special Operations Act, with a 9 pm to 5 am curfew. Police later reported recovering a loaded pistol in vegetation off La Resource South. Forensic examination must establish whether it was connected to the shootings.
The Commissioner says intelligence pointed to escalating gang violence, historical conflicts and fatal reprisals, with gangs using the development as a refuge. He has declined to disclose whether intelligence indicated imminent reprisals. Police should not expose informants or operational plans. But confidentiality cannot remove accountability for what was done with the intelligence.
The question is what action that intelligence produced. If police knew rival gangs were operating in these buildings, why restrict an entire development rather than conduct targeted, unannounced operations against people and premises suspected of harbouring illegal firearms, ammunition, drugs and other evidence of crime? What searches were carried out, what was recovered and who was arrested and charged?
In May 2022, police reported intelligence-led searches at two apartments in Building 16, Maloney Gardens; a man was later charged with seven firearm-related offences. In 2023, a senior officer told a parliamentary committee of two pockets of gangs in the Maloney district and described apartment searches that recovered marijuana, ammunition and a stolen vehicle. Another officer said four gangs in Maloney and Pinto were responsible for approximately 80 per cent of shootings, woundings and homicides in those districts. These reports concerned the wider district, not necessarily the same buildings or individuals. But gang activity was no secret.
What sustained work has since been done to dismantle these networks? Why are we again confronting the same problem with an extraordinary security measure? A closed area may establish control and deter criminal activity. But deterrence is not dismantling. A cordon is not an investigation.
The law permits a closed area only where specified serious criminality threatens public safety and ordinary law-enforcement measures cannot restore peace. The Gazette order records the statutory grounds but does not explain what ordinary measures failed. The public does not need the intelligence file, but is entitled to an account of results.
There is a wider failure. The Government has announced anti-crime strategies, mobile police posts, surveillance technology and social interventions. But announcements are not a strategy. Where is the integrated national plan, with priorities, deadlines, measurable targets and clear responsibility? A succession of operations is not a national plan.
There must also be a clear line between criminal conduct and ordinary life. At a community meeting, Senior Superintendent Avalon Frank said that “the liming by the building, the drinking, the playing cards, the selling drugs” and even “the liming by your sister and your brother and your friend to gossip” were not supposed to happen. Selling drugs is criminal conduct. Liming, playing cards, visiting family and socialising are not crimes. Police must distinguish between the two and target criminal activity, not turn ordinary social life into grounds for suspicion.
I visited Maloney Gardens on August 12, 2024. The police station is directly across from the buildings. Behind them, ordinary residents are trying to live a somewhat normal life, sometimes behind three locked gates, while gunshots ring out from the buildings metres away. They live in the shadow of violence, not responsible for it.
Some residents welcome the police presence; others describe disruption to work, family and livelihoods. Both realities deserve to be heard. Visiting family or earning an honest living does not make someone a criminal. Lawful policing deserves support; misconduct must be investigated.
The country has just come through a 199-day State of Emergency. Police reported 6,027 arrests and 1,423 people charged, alongside 326 firearms and 6,811 rounds of ammunition recovered. Those are significant operational figures. But how many of those charged have since been convicted? The public should be able to measure extraordinary policing not only by arrests and seizures, but by successful prosecutions and lasting results. After the emergency came Operation Watchtower, intended to maintain intensified policing. Now, in Maloney, we have another extraordinary security operation.
How many times can we repackage the same response and expect a different long-term outcome? Curfews, cordons, checkpoints and raids may disrupt criminal activity and buy time. But what is the plan for using that time? Where is the sustained strategy to dismantle gangs, prosecute those who direct and finance them, remove illegal weapons, strengthen investigations and prevent young people being recruited?
Without that, these operations risk becoming window dressing, visible demonstrations of State power without lasting change. The Government must show it has a crime plan beyond the next operation, one that delivers results long after the barriers and emergency restrictions are gone.
The test is not how many barriers the State erects, operations it conducts or people it arrests. It is whether people are safer when those barriers come down.
Mickela Panday is the Political Leader of the Patriotic Front and Attorney at Law
