JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Monday, July 14, 2025

ARGENTINA – Are these your true colours?

by

HAYDEN COPPIN
358 days ago
20240721
Argentina's Enzo Fernandez is congratulated after beating Canada 2-0 in a Copa America semifinal football match in East Rutherford, N.J., Tuesday, July 9, 2024. (AP Photo/Adam Hunger)

Argentina's Enzo Fernandez is congratulated after beating Canada 2-0 in a Copa America semifinal football match in East Rutherford, N.J., Tuesday, July 9, 2024. (AP Photo/Adam Hunger)

Adam Hunger

Wednes­day, Ju­ly 17th, 2024!

Mark this date down in your notepad (for those of you who still write) or in your cloud, da­ta base, or wher­ev­er you keep im­por­tant in­for­ma­tion and facts, for this could be a very his­toric date in glob­al sport­ing his­to­ry as it was on that day that Javier Milei, the Pres­i­dent of Ar­genti­na, the on­ly South Amer­i­can coun­try with a black pop­u­la­tion of less than 5%, put a sword in the hands of play­ers from around the world to make or take what could be a mas­sive step to­wards the erad­i­ca­tion of overt racism in sports!

Note: This is not a step to­wards erad­i­cat­ing racism in sports, as giv­en the rise of the ‘right’ wing agen­da in many coun­tries across the world, this is un­like­ly to hap­pen any time soon, but to stem the ris­ing overt and bla­tant dis­plays that have been ex­pressed more and more by fans and even some play­ers across the world of pro­fes­sion­al foot­ball and in fact at all lev­els.

That sword? A chance to send a mes­sage of ze­ro tol­er­ance to racism in all sports, but es­pe­cial­ly the #1 spec­ta­tor and par­tic­i­pa­tion sport in the world, that ac­tions, signs, nois­es (mon­key chants), or even songs are un­ac­cept­able and will not be ig­nored!

For those read­ers who may be won­der­ing what this col­umn is about, last Sun­day, Ju­ly 14th, En­zo Fer­nan­dez, an Ar­gen­tin­ian who plays in the mid­field for Eng­lish Pre­mier League pow­er­house Chelsea, live streamed him­self and some team­mates singing a very deroga­to­ry and dis­crim­i­na­to­ry song that tar­get­ed the black play­ers cur­rent­ly rep­re­sent­ing the France na­tion­al team.

The song was first sung af­ter the 2022 World Cup fi­nal in Qatar, where Ar­genti­na de­feat­ed France on penal­ty kicks, and some of the lyrics are: “Lis­ten, spread the word; they play for France, but they come from An­go­la. How love­ly they run! They are ‘come­travas’* like that F#%er, Mbappe. Your mom is Niger­ian, and your dad is Cameroon­ian, but their pass­port says na­tion­al­i­ty in French. (Come­travas is a slang term used in Ar­genti­na that rough­ly trans­lates to some­one who has sex with trans­gen­der peo­ple.).

What is tru­ly amaz­ing about the song and shows ex­act­ly how deep the racist ha­tred of the Ar­gen­tines to­wards the Black French play­ers is the stun­ning fact that their team had just won their sec­ond con­sec­u­tive Co­pa Amer­i­ca Cham­pi­onship by nar­row­ly de­feat­ing Co­lum­bia, an­oth­er team 80% black, 1-0, but chose to di­rect their un­war­rant­ed prej­u­dice to­wards a team thou­sands of miles away and play­ing in an en­tire­ly dif­fer­ent tour­na­ment!

How much more bla­tant can it be?

And the pas­sion, en­er­gy, and vit­ri­ol shown in the video when the song is be­ing chant­ed can­not be faked or act­ed up­on! It looked pret­ty re­al!

So, we are all hu­mans and, as such, sub­ject to mak­ing sil­ly mis­takes, say­ing or do­ing some­thing so sil­ly or stu­pid in the heat of a mo­ment, com­ing with that adren­a­lin rush cre­at­ed by the joy of cel­e­bra­tion, or, con­verse­ly, the anger and pain caused by the dis­ap­point­ment of los­ing or not achiev­ing an ex­pec­ta­tion thought to be a cer­tain­ty.

When things even­tu­al­ly calm down and heads lev­el out, most of­fend­ing par­ties do the right thing and defuse po­ten­tial­ly ex­plo­sive sit­u­a­tions, and such was the case a day lat­er when, fol­low­ing the con­tro­ver­sy cre­at­ed by the video, Fer­nan­dez is­sued the fol­low­ing state­ment: “I want to apol­o­gise for a video post­ed on my In­sta­gram chan­nel dur­ing the na­tion­al team cel­e­bra­tions. The song in­cludes high­ly of­fen­sive lan­guage, and there is ab­solute­ly no ex­cuse for these words.” Adding: “That video, that mo­ment, those words, do not re­flect my be­liefs or my char­ac­ter.”

While per­haps nowhere near enough, this apol­o­gy may have been a cat­a­lyst for cre­at­ing a path for walk­ing back the song and what it con­veyed and po­ten­tial­ly heal­ing some of the hurt and emo­tion­al suf­fer­ing that must have been in­flict­ed on hun­dreds of black play­ers Ar­genti­na’s play­ers have shared dress­ing rooms with over the years and the mil­lions of fans who have faith­ful­ly cheered them on en route to win­ning three World Cups and a cou­ple Co­pa Amer­i­ca tro­phies.

And this seemed to be the case as Ju­nior Sports Min­is­ter Julio Gar­ro came out soon af­ter and said that the song by the play­ers made the en­tire coun­try look, and it would be good to make an ex­am­ple of the sit­u­a­tion. It was fit­ting for the team’s cap­tain and most fa­mous play­er, Li­onel Mes­si, to is­sue an apol­o­gy on be­half of the team, as should the pres­i­dent of the Ar­gen­tine Foot­ball Fed­er­a­tion.

While it is un­known if an apol­o­gy from Mes­si would have quelled the storm, it sure­ly could not have hurt, but be­fore one of the great­est play­ers ever to have laced up boots could re­spond, Gar­ro was fired by the Pres­i­dent of Ar­genti­na, Milei, who backed his racist play­er by say­ing: “No gov­ern­ment can tell in­di­vid­u­als what to think or what to do on the Ar­gen­tine na­tion­al team, World Cham­pi­ons and two times Amer­i­c­as Cham­pi­ons, or to any cit­i­zen! For this rea­son, Gar­ro ceas­es to be un­der­sec­re­tary of sports for this na­tion.”

While Milei is cer­tain­ly right about in­di­vid­u­als be­ing free to “think” what they want, we all know that when a per­son pulls on a jer­sey or what­ev­er at­tire is worn to rep­re­sent their re­spec­tive coun­try, a code of con­duct is en­act­ed that strict­ly mon­i­tors and con­trols the be­hav­iour of ath­letes both in­side and out­side their par­tic­u­lar sport or en­deav­our!

Fail­ure to ad­here to this code, which gov­erns both words, ac­tions, and deeds, of­ten leads to sus­pen­sions, fines, and even ex­clu­sion from teams!

With­in the past few days, Japan has ex­pelled the cap­tain of their artis­tic gym­nas­tics team head­ing to the Paris Olympics for the griev­ous and heinous of­fence of'smok­ing a cig­a­rette’! This was against the team’s code of con­duct!

But for those in the know about Ar­genti­na’s his­to­ry, and there seem to be a shock­ing­ly small per­cent­age of these, the song by the play­ers and the back­ing of their pres­i­dent shouldn’t be a sur­prise as the coun­try has a ‘dark’ his­to­ry in deal­ing with black and in­dige­nous peo­ple in the coun­try, in which 97% of a pop­u­la­tion of 46.2 mil­lion iden­ti­fy as Eu­ro­pean!

You read cor­rect­ly! 97% con­sid­er them­selves white while shar­ing a con­ti­nent with Brazil: pop­u­la­tion: 215 mil­lion (51% black or mixed); Co­lum­bia: 52 mil­lion (51% mes­ti­zo or mixed); Venezuela: 28.3 mil­lion (51% mes­ti­zo or mixed). Pe­ru 34 mil­lion (60% mixed); Chile 19.6 mil­lion (30% mixed); Bo­livia 12.2 mil­lion (68% mixed). Uraguy has 3.4 mil­lion peo­ple (10% black and mixed).

It should be of in­ter­est to note that up to the year 1710, over 50% of Ar­genti­na’s pop­u­la­tion was black, just like all of its neigh­bours, who de­pend­ed on kid­napped and then en­slaved Africans for labour on their mas­sive plan­ta­tions.

How, then, is Ar­genti­na now 97% white? And in fact, due to re­vi­sion­ist his­to­ry, it has al­ways been this way?

This view is so wide­ly ac­cept­ed that for­mer Pres­i­dent Car­los Men­em, who once fa­mous­ly de­clared, “In Ar­genti­na, blacks do not ex­ist. That’s a Brazil prob­lem!” This view that Ar­genti­na’s pop­u­la­tion has al­ways been as it cur­rent­ly is is now wide­spread and be­lieved by the vast ma­jor­i­ty of the pop­u­la­tion, as this is ac­tu­al­ly taught in schools!

His­to­ry ac­tu­al­ly shows that be­tween 1868 and 1874, then Pres­i­dent Domin­go Sarmein­to un­der­took a covert geno­cide of black and in­dige­nous peo­ple, and this was fol­lowed up with the ob­jec­tive of mak­ing Ar­genti­na an all-white ex­ten­sion of West­ern Eu­rope by sep­a­rat­ing the non-whites and plac­ing them in squalor with no de­cent health­care, ed­u­ca­tion, or in­fra­struc­ture.

There was al­so forced re­cruit­ment of black men in­to the mil­i­tary, where they were placed in the front lines and most dan­ger­ous po­si­tions in the Paraguayan War of 1864, killing tens of thou­sands, while thou­sands more were placed in pris­ons and mass camps for the slight­est in­farc­tions and even fab­ri­cat­ed crimes.

This an­ni­hi­la­tion of the male pop­u­la­tion af­fect­ed the gen­der bal­ance to such a huge ex­tent that the women were forced to have chil­dren with white or mixed Ar­gen­tine men, fur­ther re­duc­ing the black gene pool, a trend that con­tin­ued un­abat­ed over the years un­til an African-look­ing Ar­gen­tine is a rar­i­ty and see­ing an African-look­ing per­son rep­re­sent­ing that coun­try is com­pa­ra­ble to a sight­ing of Kyawthuite, an or­ange min­er­al con­sid­ered the rarest thing in the world! In fact, this writer has nev­er seen a black per­son rep­re­sent Ar­genti­na in over 40 years of watch­ing sports!

So here we are in 2024 with a video that is undis­putable and clear­ly demon­strates to the world ex­act­ly how “some” Ar­gen­tines still think about black peo­ple.

It is im­por­tant to note that while his­to­ry and the ac­tions of those in the video paint a com­pelling pic­ture, it is not sug­gest­ed that all Ar­gen­tines are racists or share the views ex­pressed by the lyrics of the chant!

How­ev­er, the mo­ment does present what could be a wa­ter­shed op­por­tu­ni­ty for lead­ing and in­flu­en­tial black foot­ball play­ers to take a stand against racism in sports, es­pe­cial­ly foot­ball, the world’s most pop­u­lar sport, both played and watched!

Imag­ine Re­al Madrid play­ers Kylian Mbappe, Vini­cius Ju­nior, and Jude Belling­ham—all black and ar­guably in the top five of the game’s best play­ers—tak­ing a stand that un­less any Ar­gen­tine play­er on their squad pub­licly re­nounces the chant, they are not tak­ing the field with them.

Imag­ine this po­si­tion be­ing adopt­ed by promi­nent black play­ers all across Eu­rope and every­where else in the world, where Ar­gen­tines share dress­ing rooms with black team­mates. Not just in foot­ball, but in all sports!

What an im­pact this would have! What a blow to racists and racism! Play­ers and oth­ers would think a few times be­fore they re­peat­ed a sim­i­lar ac­tion!

The onus must al­so be with Wes­ley Fo­fana, a team­mate of Fer­nan­dez at Chelsea, and the per­son ini­tial­ly re­spon­si­ble for orig­i­nal­ly post­ing the video and first de­scrib­ing it as un­in­hib­it­ed racism. He has tak­en a ba­by step by un­fol­low­ing the Ar­gen­tine on so­cial me­dia along with club mates Ma­lo Gus­to and Alex Dis­asi, while Chelsea has launched an in­ter­nal in­ves­ti­ga­tion. But there is a lot more that can be done.

Most play­ers may not be as promi­nent as the RM trio named, but col­lec­tive­ly, they have pow­er, and just like black quar­ter­back Col­in Kaeper­nick of the San Fran­cis­co 49ers took a knee to high­light dis­pro­por­tion­ate po­lice vi­o­lence against black peo­ple in the Unit­ed States, their voic­es and ac­tions too can be heard and can make a dif­fer­ence!

Sur­pris­ing­ly, there is an­oth­er usu­al­ly very loud and vo­cal group that has been strange­ly qui­et on this mat­ter. The LBGTQ com­mu­ni­ty!

This group of­ten ac­cus­es so­ci­ety of dis­crim­i­na­tion and big­otry; it is there­fore shock­ing that the song’s ref­er­ence to Mabappe hav­ing sex with a trans­gen­der per­son has re­ceived so lit­tle re­sponse or push­back from LBGTQ ad­vo­cates across the world. Well, at least up to the time of writ­ing!

But it is still ear­ly days, and much more may yet be to come.

An­oth­er group that should come un­der scruti­ny will be these die-hard peo­ple of colour who have sup­port­ed Ar­genti­na over many decades and who claim that the pol­i­tics or ide­ol­o­gy of a coun­try should have noth­ing to do with sports or which team they sup­port!

Af­ter this in­ci­dent, the po­si­tion of the Pres­i­dent, and per­haps ex­po­sure to the true his­to­ry of Ar­genti­na, maybe they will re­con­sid­er wear­ing the white and sky-blue shirt in pub­lic, and while it’s fine to love the mu­sic of con­vict­ed pae­dophile R. Kel­ly’s or en­joy movies pro­duced by sex abuser Har­vey We­in­stein, there are not many who would pub­licly speak out for them or wear a T-shirt with their faces!

The next few days should in­deed be very in­ter­est­ing.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored