JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Sunday, July 27, 2025

Holder ‘lost’ as a captain but a good player — Sir Andy

by

Sports Desk
1656 days ago
20210114
West Indies Test captain Jason Holder

West Indies Test captain Jason Holder

Courtesy CWI

BRIDGETOWN, Bar­ba­dos – Sir Andy Roberts has de­scribed all-rounder Ja­son Hold­er as a “damn good crick­eter” but says he is “lost” as a cap­tain, and should look to the coach­ing staff for help dur­ing match­es.

Point­ing to his field place­ments, the out­spo­ken leg­endary for­mer West In­dies pac­er slammed Hold­er as be­ing too “de­fen­sive mind­ed”, con­tend­ing he need­ed to em­ploy a more ag­gres­sive ap­proach, es­pe­cial­ly when con­di­tions were suit­ed to fast bowl­ing.

“I would like to know how do we judge a cap­tain,” Sir Andy queried.

“Do we judge him by his win-loss record or do we judge him by his per­for­mance on the field or do we judge him on well he in­ter­views?

“I think Ja­son Hold­er as a cap­tain on the field is lost. I don’t think he is aware of what is go­ing on on the field be­cause if I win a toss as a cap­tain and be­fore lunch on a green top pitch I am hav­ing a man on the point bound­ary then I am lost.

“That’s the first thing. His field plac­ing [leaves] a lot to be de­sired and I be­lieve the time should come where he takes in­struc­tions from the coach­es who can see the game bet­ter than he can.”

Not for the first time, Hold­er’s cap­tain­cy was put un­der the mi­cro­scope fol­low­ing last De­cem­ber’s chas­ten­ing two-Test se­ries in New Zealand where West In­dies lost both match­es in­side four days by in­nings mar­gins.

Ear­li­er in 2020, he presided over a 2-1 se­ries de­feat away to Eng­land as West In­dies sur­ren­dered the Wis­den Tro­phy they had re­cap­tured in 2019 for the first time in a decade.

Over­all, Hold­er has led West In­dies in 37 of his 45 Tests but has on­ly won 11 while los­ing 21.

How­ev­er, the 29-year-old re­mains one of the world’s lead­ing per­form­ers in the Test for­mat where he was the top-ranked all-rounder for near­ly a year re­cent­ly.

He is now ranked third in the all-rounders charts, 11th in the bowl­ing rank­ings and 43rd in the bat­ting rank­ings.

While en­dors­ing the Bar­ba­di­an’s re­mark­able abil­i­ty as a crick­eter, Sir Andy said his prowess as a cap­tain need­ed to im­prove.

“A cap­tain is on­ly as good as the men who he leads so there has to be some­thing wrong with the 11 guys on the field and can­not pin­point cer­tain things to the cap­tain,” Sir Andy told Star­com Ra­dio’s Ma­son and Guest crick­et show.

“I would give him an ‘A’ grade for his in­ter­views – he in­ter­views very well. He’s a damn good crick­eter but he needs to be more ag­gres­sive in his ap­proach as a cap­tain. He’s too de­fen­sive mind­ed.”

Sir Andy al­so chid­ed Hold­er for re­cent­ly cit­ing the fa­tigue stem­ming from the bio-se­cure bub­bles as­so­ci­at­ed with tour­ing amid the on­go­ing COVID-19 pan­dem­ic.

Point­ing to the Bar­ba­di­an’s re­cent par­tic­i­pa­tion in the Aus­tralia Big Bash last month and sub­se­quent de­ci­sion to opt out of the Bangladesh tour, Sir Andy said ex­haus­tion for Hold­er and oth­er play­ers could not be used as an ex­cuse.

“I am dis­ap­point­ed with their ex­cus­es be­cause they’re tired of be­ing in the bub­ble but every­where they trav­el [for oth­er T20 tour­na­ments] they go in­to a bub­ble,” said the icon.

“If af­ter he came back from New Zealand and he said he was tired – he played two Test match­es, he bowled a few overs and he came back to the Caribbean to rest – then I wouldn’t have a prob­lem.

“But when you left New Zealand you went to Aus­tralia to bowl 16 overs and to tell me that you’re tired? You’ve got to come bet­ter than that. You have to find bet­ter ex­cus­es than that.”

(CMC)


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored