JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Wednesday, August 13, 2025

No way Jose but there are lessons

by

2428 days ago
20181221
Alvin Corneal

Alvin Corneal

Keith Clement

The man­age­ment of Man­ches­ter Unit­ed, the world’s most pop­u­lar foot­ball club, could no longer af­ford the pain and fi­nan­cial dis­as­ter and the points of demise laid at the feet of Jose Mour­in­ho.

Yes, I un­der­stand the feel­ings of the fans who were pa­tri­ots to the core and idolised the fa­mous Por­tuguese for a con­sid­er­able pe­ri­od be­cause of some suc­cess­ful re­sults along the way.

To cry for joy when his team was pro­duc­ing beau­ti­ful foot­ball and not even on those mys­te­ri­ous­ly un­fa­mil­iar days of de­feat was af­fect­ed by the sup­port sys­tem of "Man U".

For quite a few years, I had wit­nessed the work of Mour­in­ho, es­pe­cial­ly when he was the shad­ow coach un­der the watch­ful eyes of the late, great Eng­lish team man­ag­er Bob­by Rob­son.

It took a few years to de­ter­mine whether his ear­ly suc­cess was due to the lessons of his men­tor or was he a mag­nif­i­cent learn­er to the point that he was ready to show the world of his as­tute ap­proach to the busi­ness of coach­ing.

As time went on, the con­sis­ten­cy was grad­u­al­ly step­ping and the qual­i­ty of many of the top teams in the Eng­lish Pre­mier League (EPL) was em­ploy­ing some ex­cel­lent coach­es.

Mour­in­ho had to con­vince the most ar­tic­u­late “Gaffer” in Eng­lish foot­ball, Sir Alex Fer­gu­son whose con­nec­tion with "Man U" al­most brought the fans in­to think­ing that man­agers can win match­es rather than the play­ers.

How­ev­er, Mour­in­ho was hard­ly ever chal­lenged for fail­ing to de­rail the chem­istry and co­he­sive­ness of star play­ers from the for­mer vet­er­ans such as George Best, Bob­by Charl­ton and De­nis Law, lead­ing that team to­wards some ex­tra­or­di­nary bril­liance from Robin Van Per­sie to Andy Cole, to Dwight Yorke, David Beck­ham and many oth­ers.

How­ev­er, in a flash, the up­lift in foot­ball ed­u­ca­tion brought to the fore some ex­cel­lent coach­es as Mour­in­ho had to deal with the mod­ern sci­ence of sys­tems, strate­gies, game chang­ers in the mid­dle of match­es, all of these fea­tures had the mak­ing of vic­to­ry. When it was not Ar­sene Wenger, it was Manuel Pel­le­gri­ni, Rober­to Manci­ni, Pepe Guardi­o­la, Mauri­cio Pochet­ti­no and Ju­r­gen Klopp.

Sud­den­ly, the loop­holes be­gan to show them­selves as Mour­in­ho, af­ter mov­ing from one top Club to an­oth­er rapid­ly, a fea­ture which spelt ei­ther bril­liance by the coach or fail­ure to turn the ta­bles of medi­oc­rity, to a cat­e­go­ry which the ar­tic­u­late but er­rat­ic Mour­in­ho, had been ex­posed.

Dur­ing that pe­ri­od, I fig­ured young coach­es across the world would have record­ed the var­i­ous forms of meth­ods by these coach­es, which in some cas­es, pro­duced some qual­i­ta­tive play from even mid­dle of the ta­ble clubs in the EPL.

Mour­in­ho’s first blun­der seemed to be his abil­i­ty to grasp the true qual­i­ty of the play­ers in his own team, failed to com­mu­ni­cate well with good play­ers who need­ed the ex­pe­ri­ence of a good coach­ing mind and ef­fec­tive coun­selling on and off the field.

His top­sy-turvy re­sults ex­posed his weak­ness­es, es­pe­cial­ly when he was able to pur­chase ex­cel­lent play­ers in Paul Pog­ba, Alex­is Sanchez, An­tho­ny Mar­tial, to join the likes of An­to­nio Va­len­cia, Ash­ley Young, Juan Ma­ta, and a goal poach­er in Romelu Lukaku, on­ly to see the stan­dard of the team’s per­for­mances de­te­ri­o­rat­ed against some of the mid­dle-or­der teams.

Just the time which Mour­in­ho had to show his worth, he failed mis­er­ably to con­vince these top play­ers that his phi­los­o­phy which brought him pre­vi­ous suc­cess had be­come dor­mant.

His out­ward re­sponse to ac­tions by play­ers on the field and be­fore the TV cam­eras af­ter match­es may well have been the fi­nal weak­ness of a once suc­cess­ful team man­ag­er.

It was then clear that his dis­ap­point­ment with play­ers dur­ing the match­es had at­tract­ed some un­usu­al be­hav­iour from the coach’s bench, ges­tic­u­la­tion filled with anger, which of­ten caused con­flict with the of­fi­cials.

Even a blind man could have sensed the bit­ter­ness among the man­age­ment and the play­ers while the re­sult was the ab­sence of key play­ers on the bench with­out good rea­son.

That sit­u­a­tion was clear­ly erod­ing the com­radery among the group and the com­mit­ment which was need­ed from pro­fes­sion­al play­ers was not forth­com­ing. Sus­pen­sions for the coach for ir­re­spon­si­ble be­hav­iour on the bench, silent whis­pers about key play­ers seek­ing to move to oth­er clubs and some of the most dis­gust­ing in­ter­views by the for­ev­er an­gry man­ag­er, may well have been the fi­nal nail in the cof­fin for Mour­in­ho.

The re­place­ment at this junc­ture must have been a headache for the team and on­ly the fu­ture will be if some “ma­gi­cian” will turn this puz­zle in­to the team that was Man­ches­ter Unit­ed. Ac­tu­al­ly, a move which may have been help­ful could have been the use of a sports psy­chol­o­gist and a for­mer play­er, Ryan Gig­gs, who is most re­spect­ed.

A dras­tic en­gine room is need­ed in or­der to bring play­ers to their sens­es and re­mind them to re­spect their du­ty as em­ploy­ees of one of the great­est foot­ball in­sti­tu­tions in the world.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored