Two rounds of the West Indies 4-day regional championship have been completed. While we can say well done to the defending champions - Barbados Pride - and a hungry-looking Trinidad & Tobago Red Force who both registered outright victories, in my view, one of the main purposes with the England three-match Test series bowling off on March 8th in Antigua was to look at the contenders for places in that first test match.
What, then, did the West Indies selectors learn? To be truthful, absolutely nothing. I witnessed first-hand the two games at the Queen's Park Oval between Guyana Harpy Eagles and their opponents Windward Islands Volcanoes and then Leeward Islands Hurricanes, and on good batting tracks, not a single batsman in 7 innings scored a hundred. There were 13 half-centuries in the 7 days of cricket and the next step up for these batsmen is at the international level. This is simply not good enough.
I know elsewhere skipper Kraigg Brathwaite scored a massive double century but that is expected of the West Indies captain. However, he needs to be doing this at test level; and I don't necessarily mean double hundreds, but to specifically be more consistent and score runs at the top of the order to give his team a good start.
The Jamaican Scorpions skipper, John Campbell, also weighed in with a hundred but he has to score consistently at the regional level and not just one hundred interspersed with 45 and other low scores. Obviously, he has been selected based on a 53.25 average and his knock of 127, but is one knock good enough to get into the West Indies team? According to the selectors, it is. But, at the international level, it will be tough to get the required consistency. I wish him the best of luck.
Other test batsmen got half-centuries like Kieran Powell, Jermaine Blackwood, Jeremy Solozano, wicket-keeper batsmen Joshua Da Silva, Shane Dowrich, Chanderpaul Hemraj and Vishaul Singh. Interestingly enough, Devon Thomas was the most consistent with 2 half-centuries and a century but I am not surprised the selectors did not go for him despite the form he has shown. Thomas needs to curb his attacking instincts, bat for long and build an innings. I suppose one might ask that if a player can be that consistent, why does he have to bat for long and build an innings? I looked at Thomas closely while he was at the crease and he does give the bowlers a chance with his attacking instinct and I can see bowlers at the international level working him out and just waiting for a miscue. If Thomas, who has been selected for the President's XI, seriously wants to play test cricket and has the ability, he needs to settle down and hopefully, the selectors would have no choice but to eventually include him based on his consistent scores.
Some of the other batsmen who play at test level did not get a half-century and it is indeed worrying. Shimron Hetmyer, who looked the part in his first knock, deteriorated thereafter and just seems to be a poor imitation of the player that we all know he can be. My thoughts are that if you can't get a century at the regional level, how are you going to step up and do it in the test arena? Similarly, I have always said that when a player goes back to his club from representing Trinidad & Tobago and plays in his national domestic league, he should score a hundred as he is expected to be a cut above the rest.
Of the other batsmen on show, I liked the look of Alick Athanaze. At 22 years old, he can be worked with as he seems to have the right attitude, but again, needs to turn half-centuries into centuries.
The bowling also was nothing special as too many bowlers bowled an inconsistent line and length. One can get away with bowling two bad deliveries in an over at the regional level but at the Test level, the better batsmen will wait on the bad deliveries and put them away. The quick bowlers lost their line every time they tried to bowl a faster ball with the exception of Alzarri Joseph who bowled with fire and really tested the Guyana batting lineup. In my view, I am not surprised to see his name in the squad for the first test. The tried and tested duo from Guyana's Veerasammy Permaul and Gudakesh Motie with their left arm spin were among the wickets.
Two offspinners that are holding up their hands are Bryan Charles and Kenneth Dember but it is early days yet and when one looks at the West Indies attack, it lacks the variation necessary at test level. Jomel Warrican is another left-arm spinner whom I thought would have just gotten the nod ahead of Permaul in the final squad. Where are the young leg spinners or the left-arm back of the hand unorthodox bowler the West Indies need? Talented wrist spinners are badly lacking in the region and if not found quickly, the West Indies bowling attack will create nothing different in terms of spinners for world-class batsmen.
The fast bowling department cupboard seems to have a little more. The progress Jayden Seales and Anderson Phillip have made encouraging. They are young, talented and eager to do well on the world stage. I understand that Marquino Mindley bowled well in the first round and the selectors can look at one or two other performances among the fast bowlers to push Kemar Roach and Jason Holder for a place, even though I expect both to play in the first test. The selectors have not diverted much from the tried and tested squad that have made up the West Indies test team over the last two years and it is a pity more players did not raise their hands in the first two rounds of regional competition to give the selectors a headache in selecting the squad. On that note, I feel for young Jeremy Solozano as I thought he should have been given the opportunity to at least feature in the first test. Let us hope his replacement does the job the selectors are asking for. Time will tell.
In closing, let us congratulate T&T's women footballers on their two victories against Nicaragua and Dominica as they battle to qualify for next year's FIFA Women's World Cup in Australia and New Zealand. But seriously, can someone please tell me what is the official name of T&T's national women footballers? One minute I hear Women Warriors which identifies with nothing, another minute I hear Women Soca Warriors then Ladies Warriors. I remember in the past our netballers were Calypso Girls. That is why I love the Jamaican team. The men are Reggae Boyz and the women are Reggae Girls, easily identifiable with Jamaica therefore I believe the word 'soca' identifies with T&T and must be included. I always liked Soca Princesses as it identified the music and the regal stature of the women however, if one wants to have Soca Warriors then let's call them Soca Women Warriors but please, let us identify our women one way or the other.
Editor's note: The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of any organisation of which he is a stakeholder.
