JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Friday, July 18, 2025

West Indies U-19s face the critics: Coach, Captain?

by

Colin Murray
1982 days ago
20200213
Colin Murray

Colin Murray

My last col­umn in­evitably cre­at­ed some de­bate amongst some of our crick­et fans as I re­ceived a few emails from sup­port­ers giv­ing me their opin­ion on what the Un­der-19 team should have done to win the quar­ter-fi­nal match against New Zealand. The most con­sis­tent view was that Jay­den Seales should have bowled in the last few overs against the Ki­wis.

Un­doubt­ed­ly the most in­ter­est­ing email was one which read, “COACH GRAEME WEST SHOULD BE FIRED” - a strong state­ment in­deed. The crick­et fan went on to sug­gest that he should shoul­der the blame while ques­tion­ing per­haps xeno­pho­bi­cal­ly, why a for­eign­er should be coach­ing our up and com­ing crick­eters in the first place.

Fi­nal­ly, he wrote about how Crick­et West In­dies (CWI) should stop ap­point­ing “nice boy” im­age cap­tains and in­stead opt for ag­gres­sive cap­tains in the fu­ture. While I agree with this last com­ment, it is un­for­tu­nate as St Lu­cian Ki­mani Melius may have shown all the right qual­i­ties of lead­er­ship dur­ing the last year and, to be frank, ag­gres­sive U-19 lead­ers can be dif­fi­cult to find.

At the U-19 lev­el, you have to have con­fi­dence in your abil­i­ty to lead. You must be able to make quick de­ci­sions based on how the game is go­ing; analysing the bats­men, as­sess­ing your bowlers and en­sur­ing one bowls them at the right time; mak­ing sure one has the right field­s­men in the cor­rect po­si­tions; mo­ti­vat­ing the team while on the field.

Most U-19 cap­tains are un­like­ly to have much ex­pe­ri­ence in terms of play­ing first-class crick­et. It is sel­dom easy to se­lect a cap­tain un­less the young­ster from ear­ly shows lead­er­ship qual­i­ties. Young Melius made an er­ror in his de­ci­sion as to who should bowl at the death but he will be stronger at the end of the tour­na­ment.

The com­ments about the coach to me are far more note­wor­thy than that of the cap­tain. The Windies sup­port­er felt that our fail­ure to win the U-19 World Cup is large­ly due to the fail­ure of the head coach. Ad­mit­ted­ly, I nev­er thought about this no­tion un­til I met a for­mer West In­dies play­er who ex­pressed the same opin­ion to me and it made me sit up and ques­tion: did we fail?

The easy an­swer is yes, we failed to win the U-19 World Cup but what was the man­date of the coach? It was to win the tour­na­ment rather than see us put up a good show­ing so I sup­pose CWI would not be hap­py with our fifth-place fin­ish. Are we a bet­ter team than our fifth place sug­gests? If so, then the coach has to take full re­spon­si­bil­i­ty, raise his hand and say that we could and should have done bet­ter and failed to ex­e­cute prop­er­ly in cer­tain ar­eas.

When this new ad­min­is­tra­tion took of­fice, they open­ly said that our West In­di­an-born coach­es would have the first call on be­ing se­lect­ed to coach the re­spec­tive re­gion­al teams. While this is true with both the men's and women's teams, fans ques­tioned the ap­point­ment of West for the U-19 team, es­pe­cial­ly as it is the young­sters we are speak­ing about. I have not seen the cre­den­tials of Mr West but I ex­pect that they are up to scratch. How­ev­er, if CWI is true to their word, then how did the name of Graeme West fea­ture be­fore some of our coach­es? Is it that our coach­es are not qual­i­fied enough? Is it a ques­tion of ex­pe­ri­ence? Or is it West be­ing the in­cum­bent that he was sim­ply re­tained?

In our se­nior men's team, the bat­ting coach and the team an­a­lyst are two for­eign­ers ap­point­ed by coach Phil Sim­mons and skip­per Kieron Pol­lard to work with the squad. I have no prob­lem with those ap­point­ments sim­ply be­cause Sim­mons and Pol­lard re­quest­ed them as all coach­es feel most com­fort­able work­ing with cer­tain in­di­vid­u­als who they be­lieve will do the job best. It is time CWI looks at our own to coach the younger teams as we want them to play with the West In­di­an flair but be dis­ci­plined in do­ing so.

Un­sur­pris­ing­ly, Seales and Ny­eem Young made the U-19 all-star team and I re­main con­fi­dent that agents will be hound­ing them down for their sig­na­tures. I just hope they seek the right ad­vice as they are two play­ers des­tined for a great fu­ture.

I thought Ash­mead Nedd might have forced his way in­to the All-Star XI based on his fine bowl­ing dur­ing the tour­na­ment but the se­lec­tors seem to have gone on per­for­mance rather than a bal­anced team as they se­lect­ed three leg break and goo­gly bowlers in Shafiqul­lah Gha­fari from Bangladesh and the In­di­an pair of Yashasvi Jaisw­al and Ravi Bish­noi.

Per­haps most im­por­tant­ly, have you no­ticed that the top three teams in the tour­na­ment all came from the In­di­an sub­con­ti­nent? It may be that these na­tions - Bangladesh, In­dia, and Pak­istan - are plac­ing more em­pha­sis on get­ting young­sters in­volved in the game of crick­et than the oth­er na­tions.

CWI must in­sist that the re­spec­tive boards take a deep­er in­ter­est in their de­vel­op­ment pro­grammes from U-10 lev­el or these teams will dom­i­nate for many years to come. We have two years to plan for the next ICC U-19 World Cup which will be on home soil - an added im­pe­tus to not let it slip.

Ed­i­tor's note

The views ex­pressed in this col­umn are sole­ly those of the writer and do not re­flect the views of any or­gan­i­sa­tion of which he is a stake­hold­er.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored