JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Wednesday, June 18, 2025

Rebuilding pan's mythology

A re­view of the film Pan, Our Mu­sic Odyssey

by

20141120

There's a mo­ment right in the mid­dle of Pan, the new film about the na­tion­al in­stru­ment writ­ten by Kim John­son and di­rect­ed by Jerome Guiot that sum­maris­es all the hopes that the cre­ative team have for their sub­ject.

The film's lead, Re­nal­do Fred­er­ick, play­ing Gold­teeth, is walk­ing across an im­pos­si­bly beau­ti­ful for­est clear­ing, lush green as far as the eye can see, his raw, un­fin­ished in­stru­ment in a burlap sack slung over his back.

Fred­er­ick's back is to us. He is walk­ing away from a trou­bled past to a ver­dant fu­ture rich with po­ten­tial. His in­stru­ment, the source of all his hopes, just a weighty promise in its rough con­tain­er, a bur­den, by every pos­si­ble de­f­i­n­i­tion of the word.

But the ac­tor's walk is con­fi­dent and sure as he puts one foot in front of the oth­er head­ing in­to an un­known fu­ture.

It would be won­der­ful if we could con­sid­er this an at­trac­tive ar­ti­fact out of the past of the steel­band, but it's al­so a star­tling re­minder that more than a cen­tu­ry af­ter the in­stru­ment's in­ven­tion, it is still to find it­self on the oth­er side of that field, prop­er­ly po­si­tioned against and among all the mu­si­cal in­stru­ments of the world.

At least part of the rea­son for that is abun­dant­ly on show in the film, which chron­i­cles both a fic­tion­al con­den­sa­tion of the many tri­als and chal­lenges that the steel­pan had on its path to be­com­ing a main­stream mu­si­cal in­stru­ment in this coun­try and a doc­u­men­tary up­date on where the steel­band move­ment finds it­self to­day.

The weav­ing of two such wild­ly di­ver­gent sto­ries dove­tails more neat­ly that any sto­ry treat­ment might have sug­gest­ed. The chal­lenges and is­sues that served to ad­vance the ac­cep­tance and im­prove­ment of the in­stru­ment have al­so worked to cre­ate a bu­reau­cra­cy that keeps it from soar­ing even fur­ther.

John­son pays close at­ten­tion to what his doc­u­men­tary is record­ing, and deft­ly tai­lors the nar­ra­tive of his fic­tion­al his­to­ry to more smooth­ly fit in­to the flow of the re­al world footage, which fol­lows the par­al­lel sto­ries of Phase II Pan Groove, Neal and Massy All Stars and Bird­song as they pre­pare for the 2013 Panora­ma com­pe­ti­tion.

The film­mak­ers and I crossed paths cor­dial­ly in Phase II's pa­n­yard in Jan­u­ary of that year as the band be­gan pulling its pans to­geth­er to re­hearse the com­po­si­tion by arranger Len "Boogsie" Sharpe that would even­tu­al­ly win the com­pe­ti­tion.

We both had to run the gaunt­let of the band's man­age­ment in se­cur­ing per­mis­sion to pro­ceed with our projects, my own pre­sen­ta­tion be­ing in sup­port of a pho­to es­say on the Phase II jour­ney to the big yard.

Such ex­ec­u­tive im­pri­matur did not guar­an­tee ac­cep­tance for me, how­ev­er. Pan men tend to be deeply sus­pis­cious of peo­ple with cam­eras. They are smart enough to know our lit­tle mag­ic box­es don't steal souls, but savvy enough to re­alise that they are per­fect­ly ca­pa­ble of cap­tur­ing and trans­port­ing the soul of what they do in­to medi­ums far from their con­trol.

Even­tu­al­ly, af­ter pub­li­ca­tion of my piece (http://ow.ly/Eg­N­rl), I earned some kind words from some of the band's pan­nists who had ear­li­er giv­en me the stinky eye.

I can on­ly imag­ine the mag­ni­fi­ca­tion in scale of their ap­pre­ci­a­tion of the ef­forts of Kim John­son, whose great love for the steel­band per­me­ates the film.

Faced with the chal­lenge of con­dens­ing a mono­lith­ic his­to­ry for an in­stru­ment that is so deeply root­ed in the cul­ture of T&T that it would be im­pen­e­tra­ble to all save the most com­mit­ted non-lo­cals, John­son has sim­pli­fied.

His char­ac­ters are stand-ins for mul­ti­ple per­sons, some­times dozens of them, who were all work­ing in dif­fer­ent ways to im­prove both the in­stru­ment and the lot of its mu­si­cians.

The many sto­ries of the move­ment's slow but steady drift from the fringes of so­ci­ety to its heart are im­plied quick­ly and briskly through the ex­pe­ri­ences of Gold­teeth and his broth­er, the many clash­es con­densed in­to two fights, the trou­bled re­la­tion­ship be­tween the colo­nial elite and the cit­i­zen­ry be­come a lawyer's in­ter­ven­tion with a mag­is­trate to save a young boy from jail.

The re­sult is a film that hums along briskly, skip­ping like a stone across a vast pond of his­to­ry to weave the two skeins of sto­ry­telling to­geth­er.

As John­son ar­gued at a pri­vate view­ing of the film a week ago, it is a pan film, not the pan film, just one in what he hopes will be many more that tell the re­mark­able sto­ry of the in­stru­ment and the peo­ple who shaped it.

What Pan! Our Mu­si­cal Odyssey emerges as most suc­cess­ful­ly is a first ef­fort by lo­cal tal­ents to tell one of our most re­mark­able sto­ries. The film is a heart­felt ef­fort to of­fer the sto­ry of the steel­band from our point of view, freed of the ro­mance and pa­tron­age of first world per­spec­tives.

And it is here that the film res­onates most ef­fec­tive­ly. By draw­ing in and plac­ing on cen­tre stage peo­ple who would have been treat­ed as ex­tras in a film des­tined for the tra­di­tion­al cin­e­ma cir­cuit, John­son, Guiot and pro­duc­er Jean Michel Gib­ert have of­fered up a film that rings true for even the most cyn­i­cal lo­cal mind.

You don't have to love pan to love Pan. At its best, it salutes the spir­it of in­ven­tion, the grit of qui­et de­ter­mi­na­tion and the fire of undimmed hope that has sparked the best in every sphere of prac­tice that finds T&T na­tion­als ris­ing to the top.

Pan may be the sto­ry of Gold­teeth and three steel­bands, but it is al­so the sto­ry of Chang and Vau­crosson, of Min­shall and Berke­ley, of Hase­ly Craw­ford and Ato Boldon, of Pen­ny Com­mis­siong and Wendy Fitzwilliam.

It is a sto­ry of courage in the face of stag­ger­ing odds, keep­ing faith in the face of cyn­i­cism and be­liev­ing, al­ways be­liev­ing.

�2 Pan! Our Mu­sic Odyssey is be­ing screened na­tion­wide at Movi­eTowne, Cin­e­mas 8 and Em­pire Cin­e­mas, San Fer­nan­do.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored