JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Sunday, July 13, 2025

De la Bastide, Mc Nish back retrospective PM pension bill

by

KEVON FELMINE
13 days ago
20250701

KEVON FELMINE

Se­nior Re­porter

kevon.felmine@guardian.co.tt

Two In­de­pen­dent Sen­a­tors have backed Gov­ern­ment’s con­tro­ver­sial bid to ap­ply a law retroac­tive­ly to re­voke a prime min­is­te­r­i­al pen­sion for Stu­art Young, who held of­fice for just 30 days.

Michael Si­mon de la Bastide, SC, and Court­ney Mc Nish spoke in sup­port of the Prime Min­is­ter’s Pen­sions (Amend­ment) Bill, 2025, which would dis­qual­i­fy for­mer prime min­is­ters from re­ceiv­ing pen­sions if they served less than one year and demit­ted of­fice af­ter March 10.

Young be­came prime min­is­ter on March 17, 2025, and served un­til April 28, when the Peo­ple’s Na­tion­al Move­ment lost the Gen­er­al Elec­tion. Un­der the cur­rent law, he qual­i­fies for a pen­sion of $87,000 a month.

De­bat­ing the bill in the Sen­ate, de la Bastide found it com­mend­able that Gov­ern­ment brought the mea­sure now, and sup­port­ed the pro­posed tiered sys­tem.

He ex­plained that the cur­rent Act en­ti­tles any for­mer prime min­is­ter to the full pen­sion with­out re­gard to their time in of­fice, some­thing he de­scribed as un­fair and un­de­served in the eyes of “most right-mind­ed peo­ple.”

The bill’s ret­ro­spec­tive clause, which has drawn le­gal scruti­ny, would re­voke the pen­sion of any prime min­is­ter who served for less than a year af­ter March 10, 2025. This af­fects on­ly Young.

“There is on­ly one per­son, as we know as of to­day, who has left the Of­fice of the Prime Min­is­ter since March 10. There is no doubt in my mind that the Act has the ef­fect of de­priv­ing him of prop­er­ty and with­out com­pen­sa­tion. I think, in my view, with­out due process of law, and that would im­pinge on his right un­der Sec­tion 4A of the Con­sti­tu­tion—of that fun­da­men­tal hu­man right,” de la Bastide said.

How­ev­er, de la Bastide ar­gued that the law would not vi­o­late the Con­sti­tu­tion.

He ac­knowl­edged Sen­a­tor An­tho­ny Viera’s con­cerns about the rule of law but dis­agreed that the ret­ro­spec­tive na­ture vi­o­lates it. While ret­ro­spec­tive laws of­ten stir le­gal and eth­i­cal ques­tions, they are not in­her­ent­ly un­con­sti­tu­tion­al. De la Bastide said Par­lia­ment has the pow­er to act and cor­rect the mis­take that al­lowed a full pen­sion for such brief ser­vice.

Mc Nish, who spoke ear­li­er in the de­bate, said the coun­try is watch­ing how Par­lia­ment han­dles the mat­ter. He shared that peo­ple he con­sid­ered friends had called him in dis­be­lief yes­ter­day as he pre­pared for the de­bate.

“One tried to dis­guise his voice, say­ing to me, ‘Court­ney, you can­not let the man get a mil­lion dol­lars a year for 30 days’ ser­vice.’ An­oth­er per­son called with the same ex­pres­sion.”

He sug­gest­ed the is­sue might have been avoid­ed had Young sim­ply de­clined the pen­sion.

“If he had said that, we would not be here to­day. It is not my busi­ness to say what he should do, but by him not do­ing that, we are now caught in a dis­cus­sion of what is fair and what is the law.”

Mc Nish said ret­ro­spec­tive laws are not al­ways un­con­sti­tu­tion­al and can be jus­ti­fied in the pub­lic in­ter­est. He ad­mit­ted gov­ern­ments had over­looked this le­gal gap for 56 years but be­lieved now was the time to act.

Govt bench mounts de­fence

With for­mer prime min­is­ter Dr Kei­th Row­ley’s 47 per cent salary in­crease still haunt­ing the Peo­ple’s Na­tion­al Move­ment (PNM), Labour Min­is­ter Leroy Bap­tiste de­fend­ed the Prime Min­is­ter’s Pen­sions (Amend­ment) Bill 2025 as a step to­ward fair­ness for the work­ing class.

Bap­tiste said the last PNM ad­min­is­tra­tion found “cre­ative” ways to im­prove pen­sion ben­e­fits for prime min­is­ters while ig­nor­ing decades-long pleas from work­ers in the pub­lic ser­vice.

“I have seen what has hap­pened, we all have eyes, us­ing the SRC, what hap­pened with the Prime Min­is­ter’s pen­sion. They got a nice bounce to the ounce,” Bap­tiste said.

Con­trast­ing Row­ley’s fi­nal pay bump with the plight of a for­mer Wa­ter and Sew­er­age Au­thor­i­ty (WASA) hos­pi­tal­i­ty work­er, Bap­tiste read from a What­sApp mes­sage the re­tired em­ploy­ee had sent him. The in­di­vid­ual, now re­cov­er­ing from a stroke, re­ceived no pen­sion af­ter 18 years of ser­vice.

The for­mer Pub­lic Ser­vices As­so­ci­a­tion pres­i­dent said many work­ers at WASA and the Hous­ing De­vel­op­ment Cor­po­ra­tion had served for over a decade yet were not el­i­gi­ble for pen­sions at age 60. Dai­ly-rat­ed em­ploy­ees in cen­tral gov­ern­ment, he added, have wait­ed since 1994 for a promised pen­sion plan.

“Some­how, we are com­fort­able say­ing one day equals $1 mil­lion for the rest of your life, every year. When we treat with the av­er­age work­er, col­lec­tive­ly thou­sands un­der the cen­tral gov­ern­ment, they are sim­ply not en­ti­tled to a pen­sion.”

He said the bill would not dis­ad­van­tage any­one and re­ject­ed claims that it un­fair­ly tar­get­ed any in­di­vid­ual.

“No one could jus­ti­fy a fleet­ing six weeks equal a mil­lion dol­lars a year. That sim­ply can­not be jus­ti­fied—not to the tax­pay­ers of this coun­try.”

Bap­tiste cit­ed pen­sion rules for heads of gov­ern­ment in sev­er­al oth­er na­tions like Aus­tralia, South Africa and Sin­ga­pore.

“These na­tion­al ex­am­ples af­firm the prin­ci­ples we are es­tab­lish­ing here to­day: pen­sions must be earned, not gift­ed,” Bap­tiste said.

Mak­ing his in­au­gur­al con­tri­bu­tion as Leader of Gov­ern­ment Busi­ness in the Sen­ate, Sen­a­tor Dar­rell Al­la­har said the amend­ment was not po­lit­i­cal­ly mo­ti­vat­ed.

“In the ab­sence of any ev­i­dence of any state­ments com­ing from the Gov­ern­ment side of mal­ice, or some sort of Gov­ern­ment po­lit­i­cal mo­tive, those state­ments show un­for­tu­nate­ly a pre­dis­po­si­tion against the UNC Gov­ern­ment, and I am very, very dis­ap­point­ed.”

Al­la­har said the ret­ro­spec­tive clause in the bill, while con­tentious, is not “ad hominem” in the le­gal sense. He main­tained that Par­lia­ment has the le­gal au­thor­i­ty to en­act retroac­tive laws, even those af­fect­ing fun­da­men­tal rights, so long as there is no ev­i­dence of mal­ice.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored

Today's
Guardian

Publications

During my consultation with Ms Brafit CEO Nicole Joseph-Chin, what was supposed to be a simple mastectomy bra fitting became something much deeper. Her thoughtful questions unlocked emotions I didn’t even realise I was holding in. She comforted, reassured, and helped me face the truth of what was coming. That bra wasn’t just clothing—it was the first real symbol of life after surgery.

During my consultation with Ms Brafit CEO Nicole Joseph-Chin, what was supposed to be a simple mastectomy bra fitting became something much deeper. Her thoughtful questions unlocked emotions I didn’t even realise I was holding in. She comforted, reassured, and helped me face the truth of what was coming. That bra wasn’t just clothing—it was the first real symbol of life after surgery.

During my consultation with Ms Brafit CEO Nicole Joseph-Chin, what was supposed to be a simple mastectomy bra fitting became something much deeper. Her thoughtful questions unlocked emotions I didn’t even realise I was holding in. She comforted, reassured, and helped me face the truth of what was coming. That bra wasn’t just clothing—it was the first real symbol of life after surgery.

During my consultation with Ms Brafit CEO Nicole Joseph-Chin, what was supposed to be a simple mastectomy bra fitting became something much deeper. Her thoughtful questions unlocked emotions I didn’t even realise I was holding in. She comforted, reassured, and helped me face the truth of what was coming. That bra wasn’t just clothing—it was the first real symbol of life after surgery.

Standing on business, not pity: My fight begins–Part 2

13 hours ago
Nadra Supersad

Nadra Supersad

Nadra Supersad

Nadra Supersad

Cancer couldn’t stop her–Nadra Supersad says God gives her strength

13 hours ago
Adam Bartholomew, centre, performs with the Harvard College Steelpan Ensemble at Harvard Caribbean Club’s Annual Jubilee Charity Dinner and Gala in April 2025.

Adam Bartholomew, centre, performs with the Harvard College Steelpan Ensemble at Harvard Caribbean Club’s Annual Jubilee Charity Dinner and Gala in April 2025.

Adam Bartholomew, centre, performs with the Harvard College Steelpan Ensemble at Harvard Caribbean Club’s Annual Jubilee Charity Dinner and Gala in April 2025.

Adam Bartholomew, centre, performs with the Harvard College Steelpan Ensemble at Harvard Caribbean Club’s Annual Jubilee Charity Dinner and Gala in April 2025.

Trini talent shines at Harvard and Berklee

Adam Bartholomew follows his passion for science, music, storytelling

13 hours ago
Gillian de Souza graces the cover of the book: Minding Their Own Business: Five Female Leaders From Trinidad and Tobago authored by Trini-American Joanne Kilgour Dowdy, Professor of Literacy Studies at the College of Education Health and Human Services at Kent State University.

Gillian de Souza graces the cover of the book: Minding Their Own Business: Five Female Leaders From Trinidad and Tobago authored by Trini-American Joanne Kilgour Dowdy, Professor of Literacy Studies at the College of Education Health and Human Services at Kent State University.

Gillian de Souza graces the cover of the book: Minding Their Own Business: Five Female Leaders From Trinidad and Tobago authored by Trini-American Joanne Kilgour Dowdy, Professor of Literacy Studies at the College of Education Health and Human Services at Kent State University.

Gillian de Souza graces the cover of the book: Minding Their Own Business: Five Female Leaders From Trinidad and Tobago authored by Trini-American Joanne Kilgour Dowdy, Professor of Literacy Studies at the College of Education Health and Human Services at Kent State University.

Gillian de Souza’s American culinary journey springs from T&T roots

13 hours ago