JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Thursday, June 19, 2025

Stumped VI­II - part two

Fact checking ‘a fact check’

by

Joshua Seemungal
10 days ago
20250608

On Sun­day, Guardian Sport re­vealed that while the T&T Crick­et Board (TTCB) and the Sports Com­pa­ny of T&T (SporTT) stat­ed that the TTCB re­ceived $13.6 mil­lion in fund­ing be­tween 2013 and ear­ly 2025, the TTCB was al­so re­spon­si­ble for re­quest­ing and over­see­ing an­oth­er $21.2 mil­lion for com­pe­ti­tion fund­ing.

SporTT con­firmed to Guardian Me­dia that the $21.2 mil­lion was used for the 2022 ICC Un­der-19 Crick­et World Cup, the Caribbean Pre­mier League (2022 and 2023) men’s and women’s tour­na­ments and re­gion­al bi­lat­er­al se­ries, in­clud­ing West In­dies vs In­dia (2022 and 2023).

The in­ves­ti­ga­tion al­so re­vealed that in 2022, there was a 96 per­cent de­crease in ‘TTCB fund­ing’ from SporTT. For that fi­nan­cial year (2022), ac­cord­ing to the find­ings of a SporTT in­ter­nal in­ves­ti­ga­tion in­to TTCB spend­ing be­tween 2019 and 2023, there were al­leged dis­crep­an­cies in fi­nan­cial doc­u­ments.

The in­ter­nal au­dit found that the rec­on­cil­i­a­tion process by the Sport De­vel­op­ment & Per­for­mance Unit need­ed im­prov­ing, as a for­mat for prepar­ing rec­on­cil­i­a­tion did not ex­ist, while there were no rec­on­cil­i­a­tions pre­pared for 2019 and 2020.

Guardian Me­dia now sets the record straight on friv­o­lous claims made by the TTCB and a well-known me­dia house that saw it fit to pub­lish fal­si­ties that it did not ver­i­fy or seek to ver­i­fy.

Re­port 1 - “Board Mem­bers Told Guardian Me­dia that up­on this dis­cov­ery, the trea­sur­er said he be­gan to check the fi­nan­cial doc­u­ments for pre­vi­ous years and re­alised that more than $500,000 was un­ac­count­ed for.”

TTCB re­sponse: “The ini­tial dis­cov­ery was made by the Pres­i­dent of the TTCB, Mr Az­im Bas­sarath, who iden­ti­fied blank cheques stubs in the TTCB’s cheque book and prompt­ly in­formed oth­er mem­bers of the Ex­ec­u­tive. This dis­cov­ery was not made by the Trea­sur­er, Mr Kiswah Chaitoo, as has been in­cor­rect­ly stat­ed in the ar­ti­cle.

Fact: Ac­cord­ing to meet­ing min­utes, “Both Joseph Sam Phillip and Mrs Ann Browne-John com­mend­ed Mr Chaitoo for the very good work in de­tect­ing those trans­ac­tions.”

Re­port 2: The NGC au­dit found that $2.98 mil­lion was not spent by the TTCB per the MOU. The funds were trans­ferred to oth­er cat­e­gories of spend­ing with­out ap­proval by NGC.

TTCB: This state­ment is in­ac­cu­rate. The funds were al­lo­cat­ed to oth­er line items with­in the scope of the MOU. At no point were any funds used for pur­pos­es out­side of the MOU.

Fact: NGC’s Fi­nal au­dit re­port dates March 5, 2017 - “Over the three-year term of the Agree­ment (2014 to 2016), 24% of funds ad­vanced by the Com­pa­ny was not spent by Trinidad and To­ba­go Crick­et Board (TTCB) in ac­cor­dance with the Mem­o­ran­dum of Un­der­stand­ing (MOU), i.e the agreed cat­e­gories per Ap­pen­dix #1. These funds were uni­lat­er­al­ly trans­ferred to oth­er cat­e­gories by TTCB…Funds un­der­utilised were uni­lat­er­al­ly re-al­lo­cat­ed by TTCB, amount­ing to TT$1.462 mil­lion in 2014, TT$724k in 2015 and TT$797k in 2016.

“The re­al­lo­ca­tion of un­der­uti­lized funds by TTCB with­out writ­ten ap­proval by NGC meant that the or­ga­ni­za­tion breached the re­quire­ment un­der Sec­tion (1) Clause #(IV) which states, “TTCB shall not trans­fer dis­burse­ment al­lo­cat­ed to any of the line items of the fund­ing re­quire­ment and dis­burse­ment sched­ule to items not in­clud­ed in this sched­ule un­less agreed to by NGC.”

Re­port 3: Free­dom of In­for­ma­tion Act Re­quest doc­u­ments ob­tained by Guardian Me­dia re­vealed that the TTCB re­ceived 2.8 mil­lion be­tween 2019 and 2022 from the OPM­SCF. Ad­di­tion­al­ly, sev­en crick­et zones re­ceived a cu­mu­la­tive $2.9 mil­lion in di­rect fund­ing from the OPM­SCF dur­ing those four years.

TTCB re­sponse: “The sev­en crick­et zones of the TTCB re­ceived a to­tal sum of $1.12 mil­lion from 2019 to 2022.”

Fact: Guardian Me­dia’s doc­u­ment to­talled $2,878,193, while the doc­u­ment the TTCB pro­vid­ed to the me­dia, which in­clud­ed fund­ing for 2024, to­talled $3,328,193.20.

Re­port 4: “In May 2024, the Min­istry of Sport gave the TTCB an­oth­er 7.9 mil­lion in fund­ing, as part of $16.64 mil­lion dis­trib­uted to ten na­tion­al sport­ing bod­ies.”

TTCB re­sponse: The TTCB has nev­er re­ceived any fund­ing di­rect­ly from the Min­istry of Sport.

Fact: “To­day, we are dis­trib­ut­ing a lit­tle over $16 mil­lion in sup­port to Crick­et Board, to foot­ball, to box­ing, to a num­ber of dif­fer­ent sport­ing dis­ci­plines, and this is our way of reach­ing out and ex­tend­ing sup­port, say­ing we are pret­ty much right there with your en­deav­ours.” For­mer Sports & Cul­ture Min­is­ter Sham­fa Cud­joe-Lewis, May 29, 2024. SporTT is an arm of the Min­istry of Sport and Com­mu­ni­ty De­vel­op­ment.

Re­port 5: “In 2014, TTCB Pres­i­dent Az­im Bas­sarath formed a new com­pa­ny to run the af­fairs of T&T crick­et un­der a re­gion­al first-class fran­chise sys­tem in­tro­duced by the CWI.”

TTCB re­sponse: In 2014, all ter­ri­to­r­i­al crick­et boards were man­dat­ed to es­tab­lish a sub­sidiary com­mer­cial en­ti­ty re­spon­si­ble for man­ag­ing the busi­ness of crick­et, in­clud­ing the ad­min­is­tra­tion of con­tract­ed play­ers and as­so­ci­at­ed com­mer­cial rights.

By this di­rec­tive, the TTCB con­vened a Board meet­ing on May 22, 2014, to de­lib­er­ate and ap­prove the for­ma­tion of such an en­ti­ty.

As a re­sult, Red Force Crick­et T&T Lim­it­ed was du­ly es­tab­lished by the TTCB, not by Mr Az­im Bas­sarath per­son­al­ly, as au­thored by Joshua Seemu­n­gal - in align­ment with sim­i­lar ac­tions tak­en by the oth­er ter­ri­to­r­i­al boards across the re­gion.

Fact: Ac­tu­al ar­ti­cle stat­ed “In 2014, Az­im Bas­sarath, the T&T Crick­et Board (TTCB) Pres­i­dent, es­tab­lished a new com­pa­ny to man­age T&T's crick­et af­fairs with­in Crick­et West In­dies' (CWI) re­gion­al first-class fran­chise sys­tem. This ini­tia­tive aimed to stream­line the gov­er­nance of crick­et in T&T un­der the new frame­work in­tro­duced by CWI.

The T&T Red Force is a crick­et team rep­re­sent­ing T&T that plays in the re­gion­al first-class fran­chise sys­tem.”

Ad­di­tion­al­ly, ac­cord­ing to a com­pa­ny reg­istry search, the share­hold­ers of the com­pa­ny are the T&T Crick­et Board. The com­pa­ny’s di­rec­tors are list­ed as Az­im Bas­sarath and Ar­joon Ram­lal.

Re­port 6: The board re­ceived $14.8 mil­lion more than its orig­i­nal al­lo­ca­tions be­tween 2019 and 2023. The TTCB was, at first, al­lo­cat­ed $13.4 mil­lion, but even­tu­al­ly re­ceived $28.2 mil­lion in tax­pay­ers’ mon­ey.

Re­sponse: This is com­plete­ly false. The TTCB re­ceived a to­tal of $5,251,919.52 from the Sport Com­pa­ny of T&T dur­ing the pe­ri­od 2019 to 2023 - ($4,215,615.58 in di­rect fund­ing to TTCB & $1,036,303.94 to­wards the TTWCA)

Fact: Ac­cord­ing to a SporTT In­ter­nal Au­dit Com­mit­tee’s In­ves­ti­ga­tion in­to NGB Ex­pen­di­ture for the TTCB be­tween 2019 to De­cem­ber 2023, the orig­i­nal al­lo­ca­tion bud­get to the TTCB was $13.42 mil­lion, but ac­tu­al ex­pen­di­ture for the pe­ri­od was $28.17 mil­lion. This in­clud­ed $21.2 mil­lion for crick­et com­pe­ti­tions, which TTCB, as the na­tion­al gov­ern­ing body (NGB) for crick­et, ap­plied for and processed.

The in­ves­ti­ga­tion, signed by Taig­mani Richard­son - Head of In­ter­nal Au­dit, stat­ed, “The in­ter­nal au­dit ob­tained all pay­ment pack­ages and re­viewed 100% of NGB fund­ing from SporTT to TTCB for the pe­ri­od 2019-2023.”


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored