JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Thursday, July 10, 2025

Possible changes to the economy

as a result of Venezuelan migration

by

Joel Julien
1683 days ago
20201129

There are sev­er­al pos­si­ble changes in an econ­o­my on ac­count of an in­flow of mi­grants.

There is a drift to­wards the non-trad­able sec­tor. Specif­i­cal­ly, any in­dus­try which us­es the im­mi­grant labour in­ten­sive­ly (ex­am­ple bars and pubs) will re­alise an in­crease in their out­put. This will draw some labour and cap­i­tal out of the non-pe­tro­le­um ex­portable sec­tor. This type of move would oc­cur nat­u­ral­ly on ac­count of mar­ket forces and is a type of mar­ket fail­ure as it has a neg­a­tive ex­ter­nal­i­ty im­pact on the cur­rent ac­count bal­ance.

Sec­ond­ly, firms will change the in­ten­si­ty of their skills to ab­sorb the Venezue­lan im­mi­grants. Un­for­tu­nate­ly, be­cause of the lan­guage bar­ri­er, many of these im­mi­grants will fall in­to the clas­si­fi­ca­tion of un­skilled work­ers. In such a con­text, firms tend to adapt by us­ing more un­skilled labour and per­haps even chang­ing the mode of pro­duc­tion to a more labour in­ten­sive for­mat. This can com­pro­mise learn­ing by do­ing.

To sup­port this, ref­er­ence is made to the work of Gio­van­ni Peri (2012) in The Ef­fect of Im­mi­gra­tion on Pro­duc­tiv­i­ty: Ev­i­dence from the USA.

Peri found that the im­mi­grants pro­mot­ed the adop­tion of un­skilled-ef­fi­cient tech­nolo­gies. In an­oth­er re­search ef­fort, Gon­salez and Or­te­ga (2009) in How Do Very Open Economies Ad­just to Large Im­mi­gra­tion Flows: Re­cent Ev­i­dence from Span­ish Re­gions stud­ied the labour mar­ket ef­fects of a large in­flow of im­mi­grants in­to Spain be­tween 2001 and 2006.

This study found that the growth of un­skilled labour led to a change of skill in­ten­si­ty at the in­dus­try lev­el.

The key in­dus­tries ab­sorb­ing the un­skilled labour were re­tail, con­struc­tion, ho­tels and restau­rants, and do­mes­tic ser­vices. This is al­so sim­i­lar to the find­ing of Ethan Lewis (2009) who in Lo­cal Open Economies with­in the US: How do In­dus­tries re­spond to im­mi­gra­tion found that cities in the USA which re­ceived more of a par­tic­u­lar type of labour in­creased their rel­a­tive em­ploy­ment of that type of labour in the av­er­age in­dus­try by 80 per cent as much as the city-wide sup­ply in­crease.

It is very pos­si­ble that mi­grant work­ers can be will­ing to ac­cept a low­er wage rate than na­tion­als in or­der to be able to ob­tain em­ploy­ment and this is re­flect­ed in the di­a­gram.

The fall in wages from W0 to W1 and the rise in em­ploy­ment from L0 to L1 as­so­ci­at­ed with an in­flow of mi­grants is key as it in­creas­es the re­turn to cap­i­tal and gen­er­ates an im­mi­grant sur­plus.

In this re­gard by im­prov­ing the re­turn to cap­i­tal, im­mi­gra­tion pro­vides an in­cen­tive to cap­i­tal: ei­ther from do­mes­tic or from for­eign sources.

In the long run, as the cap­i­tal stock in­creas­es the K/L ra­tio im­proves and the ini­tial de­cline in wages can be mit­i­gat­ed.

The great con­cern is the di­rec­tion in which cap­i­tal will flow. The state will have to guide this process care­ful­ly. If the state does not in­ter­vene and leaves the labour mar­ket pol­i­cy in its cur­rent for­mat, then the ser­vices and per­son­al care sec­tors will con­tin­ue to grow, and this can re­sult in bal­ance of pay­ment prob­lems as the econ­o­my moves for­ward.

The Ta­ble shows a com­par­a­tive as­sess­ment of the nat­ur­al gas fac­tor boom and the labour mar­ket fac­tor boom brought on by the in­flow of Venezue­lans (40,000 is as­sumed here).

With the nat­ur­al gas fac­tor boom, wages in the econ­o­my rose be­cause of the re­source move­ment ef­fort and the spend­ing ef­fect. Im­ports in­to the econ­o­my in­creased as the re­al ef­fec­tive ex­change rate ap­pre­ci­at­ed.

With 40,000 im­mi­grant Venezue­lan work­ers, there is al­so a rise in im­ports as Venezue­lans buy goods to send back to their home coun­try. Some of these goods will no doubt be im­port­ed in­to T&T be­fore it is re­mit­ted to Venezuela by the im­mi­grants.

With the nat­ur­al gas boom, there was an in­crease in the out­put of the goods that in­ten­sive­ly used nat­ur­al gas. Thus, am­mo­nia pro­duc­tion in­creased from 3,253,000 tonnes in 2000 to 5,532,000 tonnes in 2010.

Sim­i­lar­ly, methanol pro­duc­tion in­creased from 2,480,000 to 5,932,200 tonnes across the same time pe­ri­od. How­ev­er, oth­er non-boom­ing trad­able ex­ports fell. In the TT econ­o­my case, there was a de­cline in non-min­er­al ex­ports from $50.2 bn in 2012 to $28.3 bn in 2019.

With an im­mi­grant “fac­tor boom” if the pro­duc­tion of non-trad­able goods in­creas­es and pulls com­ple­men­tary skilled work­ers and/or cap­i­tal out of man­u­fac­tur­ing and oth­er ex­port-ori­ent­ed sec­tors then this can com­pro­mise the non-pe­tro­le­um ex­port lev­el of the econ­o­my. These trends in im­ports and ex­ports can in turn com­pro­mise the over­all cur­rent ac­count bal­ance.

Mi­grant work­ers tend to re­mit part of their in­come to their home coun­try in the form of goods or in the form of US dol­lars.

This in­creas­es the de­mand for for­eign ex­change in T&T and re­duces the al­ready de­creas­ing stock of re­serves housed at the Cen­tral Bank.

Some con­sid­er­a­tions to help man­age the mi­grant sit­u­a­tion

As a start, we need to pay more at­ten­tion to the mi­nors of refugees. If this process drags on for three to four years, we may have a bunch of il­lit­er­ate Venezue­lan boys and girls as teenagers mov­ing about T&T. This can make the man­age­ment of the so­cial fall­out from the pres­ence of these im­mi­grants in our coun­try much low­er in the fu­ture.

Per­haps the state and UN­HCR can work to­geth­er with the Catholic church to pro­vide some ba­sic amount of ed­u­ca­tion­al sup­port when the COVID-19 sit­u­a­tion im­proves?

There is a need to pro­mote Eng­lish as a For­eign Lan­guage (EFL) train­ing. This will help to en­sure that those im­mi­grants that are for­mal­ly reg­is­tered to work in T&T can bet­ter in­te­grate in­to the econ­o­my. This may re­quire them ob­tain­ing a very ba­sic Eng­lish as a for­eign lan­guage per­mit to be able to work, sim­i­lar to the PLEA (Point Lisas En­er­gy As­so­ci­a­tion) pass­port that the En­er­gy Cham­ber pro­motes.

It is al­so nec­es­sary to ex­tend COVID-19 test­ing to im­mi­grants whether they are here il­le­gal­ly or not, as fail­ure to do so may cause a spike with­in the coun­try once again, should some­one among the il­le­gal Venezue­lan com­mu­ni­ty in this coun­try, have the virus.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored