JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Monday, July 21, 2025

Holding, ICC war over poor World Cup umpiring

by

Sports Desk
2230 days ago
20190613

West In­dies fast bowl­ing leg­end Michael Hold­ing is now at the cen­tre of a World Cup um­pir­ing con­tro­ver­sy with the In­ter­na­tion­al Crick­et Coun­cil (ICC), af­ter the body re­port­ed­ly tried to cen­sure him over his crit­i­cism of de­ci­sions by the of­fi­cials dur­ing the West In­dies ver­sus Aus­tralia game last Thurs­day.

The Times of In­dia is re­port­ing that Hold­ing hit out at what he termed at­tempts at ‘cen­sor­ship’ from the ICC, af­ter an email from the body for­mal­ly chas­tised him for his on-air com­ments dur­ing the game and sug­gest­ed he cut down crit­i­cism of um­pires on air.

The Times of In­dia ac­cessed both an e-mail sent by Huw Be­van, pro­duc­tion head for the ICC’s rights part­ner Sun­set and Vine Asia, crit­i­cis­ing Hold­ing for his crit­i­cism and the for­mer Windies leg­end’s re­ply, in which he re­fused to back down on his stand.

Hold­ing had called the um­pir­ing atro­cious dur­ing the game and was not the on­ly TV com­men­ta­tor to do so. The West In­dies play­ers and man­age­ment were al­so crit­i­cal of match of­fi­cials Chris Gaffaney and Ruchi­ra Pal­liyagu­ruge dur­ing the post-match in­ter­views and Windies fans had even called on the re­gion­al board to ap­proach the ICC on the mat­ter.

On the field of play, West In­dies open­er Chris Gayle was ad­judged out twice dur­ing an over from Aussie pac­er Mitchell Starc and both calls were over­turned via the re­view sys­tem. Gayle was even­tu­al­ly dis­missed lbw on an­oth­er re­view in Starc’s next over but re­plays lat­er re­vealed the pre­vi­ous de­liv­ery from Starc was a bla­tant no-ball. The le­gal ball that dis­missed the West In­di­an thus should have been free-hit. Two more on-field de­ci­sions in­volv­ing Windies skip­per Ja­son Hold­er were al­so over­turned on re­view.

While on air, Hold­ing said he felt the um­pires were be­ing pres­sured by vo­cif­er­ous ap­peals from the play­ers as he not­ed how the game was af­fect­ed by the poor de­ci­sions.

But in re­sponse to the avalanche of crit­i­cism of the of­fi­ci­at­ing from Hold­ing and oth­er match com­men­ta­tors the day af­ter the match, Be­van sent an email to Hold­ing not­ing “the im­por­tance of main­tain­ing the high­est stan­dards and up­hold the game’s best val­ues and spir­it while cov­er­ing the tour­na­ment.”

Said Be­van: “In­her­ent­ly in live tele­vi­sion, there are oc­ca­sions when on-field de­ci­sions cause rea­son for dis­cus­sion or de­bate but as ICC TV host broad­cast­ers, our [Sun­set & Vine] du­ty is not to judge or high­light mis­takes.”

Hold­ing re­port­ed­ly asked why he was the on­ly com­men­ta­tor sin­gled out in his re­sponse to Be­van, adding: “If those um­pires were FI­FA of­fi­cials, they would have been told to pack their bags and head home. They would not have been giv­en an­oth­er World Cup game to of­fi­ci­ate. As a for­mer crick­eter, I think crick­et should be held to a high­er stan­dard. Is the ob­jec­tive to pro­tect the um­pires even when they do a bad job?”

Hold­ing re­port­ed­ly said Be­van’s email was ev­i­dence that “com­men­ta­tors are be­ing more and more com­pro­mised by con­trol­ling or­gan­i­sa­tions to the point of cen­sor­ship.”

Per­haps sens­ing his stance may have drawn a fur­ther re­sponse from the ICC, Hold­ing added, “I am sor­ry, but I am not go­ing to be part of that. Please let me know if I should be head­ing back to my home in New­mar­ket in­stead of head­ing to Cardiff be­cause I don’t agree with what is be­ing sug­gest­ed here and hap­py not be­ing part of it.”

How­ev­er, when the news­pa­per con­tact­ed Hold­ing for a com­ment, he said the mat­ter with the ICC had been re­solved and he was con­tin­u­ing on the com­men­tary team.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored